As I mentioned in my post about the Paradise DVD, I finally received my copy of Yes, Virginia - the new album by The Dresden Dolls. Before I get to the album review and mp3s, I feel the need to vent a little.
I pre-ordered the cd from Amazon months ago, but I only received it last week. Amazon jacked up the price for pre-orders, so I initially refused to pay. But my local music retailer didn't have the album in stock, so I finally paid Amazon their ransom demand. Instead of downloading the album for free, I tried to support the band by buying their album during its first week. I ended up getting screwed for my effort, paying more than retail price and receiving my pre-order a month after it was released. The music industry certainly knows how to treat loyal, paying fans. Oh well, end of pity party.
I'm happy to say that Yes, Virginia was worth the wait. The new album retains enough of the raw sound and antiqued, German Cabaret style of the band's last album, yet it is plenty different enough to keep from being a carbon copy.
Some of the songs (such as "Necessary Evil") on the new album have almost a hint of Pop to them, especially when compared to older, pleasantly disjointed works like "Girl Anachronism". Or, at least, as close to Pop as a band like The Dresden Dolls can or should come - an intense, theatrical, Glam Rock/ Rock Opera kind of Punk-Pop. In other words, the good kind of Pop. Only not Pop at all. Confused? That's part of their charm.
I think what I'm enjoying most about the new album are Amanda's clever lyrics and her vocal style, particularly her enunciation and inflection. She times each word to fit perfectly with the rhythm of the song, stretching or halting every syllable as needed to match it with its corresponding musical note. It's something that seems to be unique to her, and enhances and emphasizes the lyrics of the individual songs. Most singers seem to just sing the lyrics over the music, without paying so much attention to the intricate details of how the words and melody mesh together.
As on The Dresden Dolls' two previous albums (one studio, one live EP), the lyrics on Yes, Virginia alternate between circus sideshow litanies, to venomous, unapologetic rants about ex-lovers and ex-friends, to biting satires of modern society - all peppered with Palmer's barbed wire wit.
My one and only complaint about the new album is that they didn't include their covers of Black Sabbath's "War Pigs" and Carole King's "Pierre" on it (both featured on the Paradise DVD), but I realize they probably want to keep to original songs for these early records, and possibly wouldn't be able to get the rights to the covers. But hopefully they will make a future album including those tracks.
I was already familiar with some of the songs on the album either through live mp3s ("Sex Changes", "Backstabber", "My Alcoholic Friends") or their inclusion on the live EP, A is for Accident ("Mrs. O"). I can't really say whether I prefer the album versions or the live ones. It's the same dilemma I had with their self-titled studio album, since many of those songs had also been recorded live for A is for Accident. The live mp3s have the raw power of a concert performance, yet the studio versions have a little extra oomph and polish to them. So it's good either way, and I'm very glad to have both sets of songs to enjoy.
The album version of "Backstabber", for example, almost sounds like a completely new song. The live version was slower, with deeper, more deliberate vocals and a tone that was more bitter than vindictive. I like the album arrangement a lot more. It's got more of a polished beat, and Amanda's vocals sound more flippant and insulting. A bit like the change in Fiona Apple's "Red, Red, Red" between the Extraordinary Machine demo and the studio release. Only in reverse, as if "Backstabber" evolved from introverted rage to more of an attack stance. Just those slight changes drastically improve what was a pretty good song to begin with.
Some of the new songs are very good as well. "Mandy Goes To Med School" is pure cabaret. And "Delilah" is as about as close to a ballad as The Dresden Dolls ever get. Though, like their other almost-ballad "Missed Me", the pretty music of "Delilah" is intertwined with dark, slightly disturbing lyrics.
"First Orgasm" and "Me & The Minibar" seem to be the only real weak points on the album, but that may just be an initial, fleeting impression. It took me a while to warm to some of the tunes on their last album, and now I love them all. So I'm sure the new album will sound better with each listen, too.
I only downloaded one mp3 from Yes, Virginia before I got the album. It was hard to resist the temptation, but I think waiting to hear the songs for the first time on the cd increased my excitement and enjoyment of the album.
Tracklisting:
1. Sex Changes
2. Backstabber
3. Modern Moonlight
4. My Alcoholic Friends
5. Delilah
6. Dirty Business
7. First Orgasm
8. Mrs. O
9. Shores Of California
10. Necessary Evil
11. Mandy Goes To Med School
12. Me & The Minibar
13. Sing
DD Official Site
DD MySpace
Amanda's Diary
DD Forum
Automatic Joy (archive of live mp3s)
Buy The Dresden Dolls DVD & CDs